Last month, I proudly made a foray into fondant! My in-laws hosted Father’s Day and since my parents were coming, I thought it would be fun to make cookies for the dads.
I was inspired by the shirt-and-tie cookies from Munchkin Munchies (so cute!), but I then found these sports ball-themed cookie cutters on Amazon. Learned a lot, but what a production! In this case, I don’t feel that the effort matched the result, but it was a learning process all the same. Better yet – I now don’t feel intimidated by some of the ultra-fancy cookies I pinned on Pinterest over the last couple months. OK, I lied – I’m totally still a little intimidated, but it wasn’t as hard as I thought.
A couple of things I learned…
Make sure to get a good cookie recipe
I know this is obvious, but I’m a novice baker and I don’t have any tried-and-true sugar cookie recipes, so I used the recipe that came with the cookie cutters. Awful choice. The cookies were way too bland. Next time, I’ll find a better-tasting cookie recipe. On the upside, they turned out solid and not soft or wimpy.
Have a plan
The cookie cutter set came with so many options and it could have become an expensive project. Instead, I narrowed down the cookie shapes to sports balls that were white (golf, volleyball, baseball), brown (football) or black (billiard ball). I bought a big box of ready-to-use rolled, white fondant and a small-assorted box that included black and brown fondant.
Rolling fondant is an arm toner
Holy cow! My arms were sore the next day! I really had to put everything into the rolling-pin to roll out the fondant. Talk about elbow grease…And even then, I didn’t roll it thin enough. In order to avoid having fondant overpower the cookie’s taste, you need to roll it to a 1/8” thickness or less. Maybe using a regular rolling-pin would have helped. I used a little weenie wooden roller I bought at AC Moore in the baking aisle.
Sports Ball Cookies
I’ll skip past the recipe for the sugar cookies. Just be sure to use a recipe that yields a sturdy cookie so that it won’t break or fall apart when you lay the fondant on top. You can make the cookies the night before so they are cool. Also, you’ll need buttercream to seal the fondant to the cookie. I used Pillsbury buttercream frosting, but I think next time I’d make it from scratch.
After cookies have cooled, using a rolling-pin, roll out fondant on a clean surface or cutting board. Roll it out so that the thickness is between 1/16” and 1/8”.
Place the plastic impression on top of the fondant. Then, roll the rolling-pin over the plastic a couple of times.
Gently remove the plastic. There should be a decent indentation. Then take the cookie cutter and cut out the pattern. You may need to twist the cutter to remove the fondant.
Spread a thin layer of buttercream on the cookie.
Then, carefully place the fondant on top of the buttercream. Decorate as needed.
Overall, it was a really fun project. I also used an edible marker for the first time – doesn’t the baseball look cool?? My favorite cookie overall was the billiard ball though. I can see that this could be a fun family project with older kids or as an activity at a kid’s birthday party.
- Farm Fresh Summer Party Picks + Vintage Milk Bottle Cookies (fancyflours.com)
- Preppy Nautical Party (fancyflours.wordpress.com)
- Forever Nigella: Diamond Jubilee (sniffandsnort.wordpress.com)
- Making Fondant Flowers for Fox6 (caketalk.typepad.com)